That's a great question and I apologize for the late reply. Each amplifier you mentioned has its own merits. I have the Soulution 717 in the showroom and did a show (Pacific Audio Fest) with the Burmester 159's powering Zellaton loudspeakers:
Burmester 159: Panzer division tanks capable of cracking the cement foundation of your home. The manner in which they control a speaker is unparalleled and power delivery is the most confidence inspiring experience these ears have heard. The immediacy, attack and presence in the power range is really something special and reminds me of Symphonic Line Kraft, Krell KSA/KMA or Cello Performance brand of pure power delivery. That's not to say they aren't capable of beauty, which they are. Burmester is known for a prettier sounding SS amp and top end has a sweetness yet immediacy that makes them so lauded. Clients here have partnered Burmester with Zellaton and of course other brands, and it has a pedigree/brand loyalty that can't be dismissed or ignored.
Soulution 717: In the showroom now in constant rotation, the absolute finest to emerge from these Swiss masters. They are clearly bottom up and tonally on the darker side of the spectrum with an integrity in the midrange that is incredibly seductive. The bass performance is fast, tight yet very breathable and tonally spot on. Definitely more tonally dense and colorful when compared to older Soulution designs that could, at times, err on the dry side of life, somewhat lacking in warmth and musical touch. The new 717 now deviates from the cerebral to emotional connection, hence my admiration.
Stellavox IDEM: This is where it gets interesting and difficult for me..., so I'll start by saying that I could easily see how many audiophiles would prefer the Burmester or Soulution. In a second. The reason I say this is because the Stellavox amps have no sound at all - and for many, can fail to impress (at first). Understanding their beauty takes a counterintuitive approach as they are the most natural and liquid amps I've yet to experience. Of course they are limitless in terms of dynamics, power, control and other audiophile parameters, but where they really distinguish from others is the sheer unforced quality that allows every note, instrument and musical interplay to come through so effortlessly and with incredible delicacy. They remind me of true pure class A designs like older Levinson ML2, Threshold 12e, original Accuphase Class A, or even an 80's a/b Goldmund Mimesis 3 but with the liquidity of a Futterman OTL powering Quad 57s. So in other words, very elegant and seamless that has a way of drawing one in - as opposed to fireworks that can excite at first but fatigue later. In this sense, they are quite unique.
Concluding, these are all statement amps that appeal to subjective tastes. In the end only you know what you hear (and feel). I have them set up in the showroom and I welcome all members to come and listen.
Steve is generously planning a Stellavox event at his home which will partner with his Zellaton's. So once that date is locked in, we welcome all West Coast member to listen and judge for themselves.
Gideon
Author:
HiFi: The History of High End Audio Design
https://www.phaidon.com/store/design/hi-fi-the-history-of-high-end-audio-design-9780714878089/
Revolution: The History of Turntable Design
https://www.phaidon.com/store/design/revolution-the-history-of-turntable-design-9781838665616/