Oh jeez - M6, another super-speaker from Magico
- Thread starter ack
- Start date
Had the v1 for years. Demoed the v2, excellent speakers but the M6 better overall in most areas.
It needs to be said that DMSB is affiliated with MSB, and they have now chosen to exhibit with Magico, after using YG for years, after Magico put an MSB SELECT in their listening room.
Which is a shame, from where I'm at
Oh please. Do you always have to assume ulterior motives? Be careful, this may bite you back
.Ahh makes sense now. Probably another thread but , as it well known dealers and manufactures often team up to split the cost of their respective rooms at shows.
To that end , doesn’t make the “synergy “ or paring the best but , It’s what works for both parities involved.
I read @DMSB post and assumed he was an end user and had various brands in his own room for comparison and preferred the m6 over the Sonja 2 with the same front end.
Your post seemed to imply that DMSB had reasons to prefer Magico other than just the sound. If that is not the case, it's all good
.
It needs to be said that DMSB is affiliated with MSB, and they have now chosen to exhibit with Magico, after using YG for years, after Magico put an MSB SELECT in their listening room.
Which is a shame, from where I'm at
Alex, why does it "need" to be said? He made a comment about the sound of the Magico M6 speaker in a thread about the M6 speaker.
Malicious head, huh? Alex, I bet I am not the only one here who at the very least finds your post, shall we say, ambiguous in intent. Why then make such a post in the first place?
In this case I do agree that industry affiliations need to be disclosed. If DMSB comments Wilson is good when he is not dealing in Wilson, then that's fine
@asiufy Thank you for your post. As I've stated ; without knowing who DMSB (Daniel Gullman?) is. I assumed he was an end user that had access to many different speakers that he was trying out in his listening room and on the same electronics. The end he subjectively preferred the M6 in his system and room.
Knowing that isn't the case now. I and this in my opinion only that DMSB might have perceived bias or have some kind of business relationship with Magico. Which isn't uncommon in the industry but, as Alex made clear if the poster is or represents MSB.
That explains a lot.
Alex, you could ask the moderators to enforce their policy to mention his industry affiliation and you could contact the member directly and ask him to do it. I think that might accomplish your goals.
And then once the affiliation is clear though now it is because of your post, we can still take his comment about what he thinks of the sound of the M6.
And BTW, Alex, I had already offered the alternative that you had no ill intent, even with a conciliatory smiley face:
What does it say that you did not take it and instead needed to accuse me of having a "malicious head"?
You could simply have responded, yes, this is not the case.
If that is not the case, it's all good
What does it say that you did not take it and instead needed to accuse me of having a "malicious head"?
You could simply have responded, yes, this is not the case.
I’m sorry if I stepped in a political no go zone. In my defense, my opinion was clearly solicited and I thought I was in a position to reply because I had in depth experience with the products mentioned and no financial stake in either. To clarify my company has no financial stake in any speaker company, YG, Magico or any other. I also like both YGs and Magicos product a lot! I use speakers daily as a development tool for our products and we also use them to promote our gear at shows because we do not manufacture any ourselves. Unlike a dealer who needs to support the lines they have we have the luxury to choose anything we want to. If we need speakers or other gear we buy it. If the manufacturer wants to trade for a product we make as part of the deal then yes we love that too. In the past we have made some terrible choices of gear partners at shows for financial or political reasons but that has backfired on us too often.
In my opinion there are no perfect audio products, and with speakers its even harder to optimize every necessary attribute. I find many speakers will optimize just a handful of attributes at the expense of all others, or completely ignore a few gaping holes in their abilities. Such speakers can still be very musically enjoyable but are not very useful for me. I require speakers that have optimized the majority of attributes as much as possible and leave no gaping holes in their performance or I may inadvertently design products with lopsided performance. I also develop with multiple speakers at once because some are much better at specific things, or present very different loads, or have very different efficiencies. In some listening sessions I will listen to up to three different speakers (thats about the limit of my aural concentration and flexibility). That is the perspective I am commenting from.
In my opinion there are no perfect audio products, and with speakers its even harder to optimize every necessary attribute. I find many speakers will optimize just a handful of attributes at the expense of all others, or completely ignore a few gaping holes in their abilities. Such speakers can still be very musically enjoyable but are not very useful for me. I require speakers that have optimized the majority of attributes as much as possible and leave no gaping holes in their performance or I may inadvertently design products with lopsided performance. I also develop with multiple speakers at once because some are much better at specific things, or present very different loads, or have very different efficiencies. In some listening sessions I will listen to up to three different speakers (thats about the limit of my aural concentration and flexibility). That is the perspective I am commenting from.
One last thing before I go, which I want to make PERFECTLY clear, regardless of the crap that went down.
I think it's BRILLIANT that Magico is using MSB. I wish every single speaker manufacturer used MSB, whether we sell them or not. Heck, I wish everybody would own MSB, so they can enjoy their digital as much as I do.
That's it.
Peace, out.
Alex
I think it's BRILLIANT that Magico is using MSB. I wish every single speaker manufacturer used MSB, whether we sell them or not. Heck, I wish everybody would own MSB, so they can enjoy their digital as much as I do.
That's it.
Peace, out.
Alex
True. The admin/owner/dealer would have most likely deleted it.
Hmm, I've seen members on that forum whose views don't align with the Forum owner disappear after being banned for life to send a message to other members not to post comments/threads which are critical of product lines the owner/admin carries. So at the very least, a thread like this on his forum would be on very thin ice from day 1..
Similar threads
- Locked
 | Steve Williams Site Founder | Site Owner | Administrator |  | Ron Resnick Site Owner | Administrator |  | Julian (The Fixer) Website Build | Marketing Managersing |