What are the characteristics that differentiate analog, digital, and master tape sound? How would you rank them? Where does the sound of live, un-amplified voices and instruments fit in your ranking?
I am a HP disciple and the sound of live unamplified instruments and vocals is my goal.
The flaws in analog and digital have been discussed ad nausem and there is nor reason to do that again. These "rankings " are today meaningless as the world has changed and with it technology. I live in the present, I listen in the present and I use the technology of the present. You can purchase wonderful analog playback systems for records and I guess the same for tape if you have the library of tapes to play but that is not the only option or the most popular option. I have made my choice as I bought a Wadax others will make theirs.
In the old days it was definetly Master Tape at the top of the heap.
I am not taking about a copy of a copy of a copy of a CDor a record etc. when we discuss tape
Everyone says they have master tapes and trust me they don't. They protect those things like they are flawless diamonds.
I grew up in NY and NYC and had many recording engineers and artists as clients that were clients. We worked with Rudy Van Gelder, Sheffield Labs, CBS, RCA and others. We had on hand Studer machines and these things are far beyond the other formats at the time. We also had access frm other sources in the Industry that had these type of clients.
Wadax has a decernable absense of various types of noise. No clicks, pops, hiss, crackle etc. It is full , rich, and dynamic. It is not something that makes you want to turn it off.
The best analogy I can make is like food. Some food intitally tastes great but you quickly wna to stop eating it
other foods are really not great at all they have no flavor or they just taste bad.
however some foods you want to eat slowly and savior and make you want the experience to not end.
After all the years I have been listening, most of which I thought digital was HORRIBLE, beyond bad, and then the last 5 or so when I found that digital had finally become listenable and enjoyable. To me it has finally reached a level at which it can compete with every format and has many positive factors that others can't offer. It is the easiest to use, the best to find new music, you can play things as often as you like, there is nothing to clean, you dont need to get up to change things, it requires no huge areas of storage.