Remembering FM Radio

MylesBAstor

Reviewer
Apr 20, 2010
11,344
272
1,760
New York City
"Major Edwin Howard Armstrong

The Inventor of FM

If you head north on Route 9W to the Cresskill/Dumont line you'll see, rising 400 feet above the Palisades of Alpine, Major Edwin Howard Armstrong's grave marker. It is the antenna tower of the first-ever FM station, W2XMNF, erected in 1936 and now crowded with satellite dishes and aerials receiving and relaying all manner of television, cellular and microwave signals. And a lone FM station, WFDU, out of Fairleigh Dickinson University.
It was in the basement of another university, Columbia, that Maj. Armstrong (he served in the newly-formed Signal Corps in World War I) pioneered an entirely new form of broadcasting: static-free, crystal-clear, high-fidelity Frequency Modulation. It was the crowning achievement in a life devoted to radio and broadcasting. He single-handedly wrenched radio out of the crystal-set/headphone era with his discovery of regeneration and super-regeneration-- principles which utilize feedback to amplify and strengthen weak signals. He developed the superheterodyne-- an incredibly sensitive and selective type of receiver for the Army. He fought lengthy, expensive patent battles over most of his inventions against those hoping to discredit him and profit from his genius. And then there was FM.

It should have made him incredibly wealthy, it should have eradicated AM and become the broadcasting medium. It should have made him a household name like Edison. But Armstrong hadn't counted on corporate greed, the profit motive, and the Radio Corporation of America. RCA, a corporation engineered by the government for the purpose of developing the fledgling U.S. broadcast industry (then at the mercy of foreign concerns, like the British Marconi Company and others) by pooling the important broadcasting patents of AT&T, Westinghouse and General Electric, was not about to turn its attention away from its now infant-- television. David Sarnoff, a twenty-five year friend of Armstrong's and the president of RCA, cut Armstrong off from the only company large enough to give FM the send-up it needed. And then the real troubles began.

Plagued by endless patent suits, struggling to keep FM alive, Armstrong began pouring his own money into research, development, and refinement. He put the Alpine station on the air. He presented speeches and prepared papers for assorted engineering and broadcasting societies. He sat before numerous government hearings, bought many a lawyer's summer home and continued his obsessive quest to bring FM to the people, through a second World War and into the postwar years. He waited patiently for what should have been the explosion of FM, but for one thing-- the FCC. One of their engineers, an Alexander Ring, recommended a frequency shift for FM to "protect" it from interference. He incorrectly predicted it would become a problem every eleven years or so. On the flimsiest of pretexts the whole FM band was ordered to move "upstairs" from 42 to 50 MHz. This had the effect of nearly killing the new industry, making fifty or so transmitters and 500,000 radio sets obsolete overnight. It was just one more blow for the clear-thinking, logical and soon-to-be-destitute Armstrong.

Twenty-three years to the day after patenting FM, Maj. Armstrong put on his hat, coat, scarf, and gloves, and walked out his apartment window, 13 floors to his death."
 
As a kid I grew up on am and later fm too poor to even have a color TV . Radio was the venue , I remember using my older brothers radio.
Tubes and 3 batteries inside .
Later in my cars FM radio ruled my entertainment .
Regarding his invention, many times the maker got nothing . Edison was a smart Business man and really only made a few things. Video and sound on video if I recall
The man little know was Tesla . Westing house I think wanted to merge with Edison who was stuck on dc distribution
While Tesla wanted his ideas to be free for all
If you think about it FM was and is still free .
Velcro and many others were killed off by pure corruption of corporate greed . Your right on this Myles .
When westing house died I read he burned all his papers .
A movie the current war shows some of what went on but is not totally honest either
 
Back before digital came to market, FM radio was able to hold us captive for hours on end listening to the latest emerging hits.
 
I love FM. Because it is “Free Music”. Thank you very much Maj. Armstrong.
I just got got my fifth tuner. (I am trying to give away two of them.)

Bring back the CPB.
One of the best US government institutions. It supports and promotes education, truth, knowledge, and beautiful music.
 
Last edited:
I still love radio, but now in the form of still-free internet radio. All the stations you know and love from their FM broadcasts are streaming online for free. Often the online fidelity exceeds all but the best FM broadcast signals heard on the best tuners under the best reception conditions. Sure, you can argue that an analog signal is better, but once signal-to-noise degradation and multipath distortion are thrown in, almost never. In the Chicago area, classical music WFMT was the only station whose analog FM signal via my Sansui TU-X1 exceeded in quality what I heard from either its HD broadcast (via my Sequerra tuner) or its online digital stream (via any streamer I've ever owned, from Squeezebox Touch to my current Lyngdorf.)

And of course, now you can "receive" tens of thousands of internet radio stations from all over the world, rather than the 50 or 60 availble via FM even in large urban markets.

Internet radio aggregation services are legion. Two I currently use frequently are airable and Tune-In. Roon's Live Radio function also is VERY nice since for many stations with a couple of clicks you can move from the lossy radio version of what's playing to the Qobuz or Tidal CD or better quality version.
 

About us

  • What’s Best Forum is THE forum for high end audio, product reviews, advice and sharing experiences on the best of everything else. This is THE place where audiophiles and audio companies discuss vintage, contemporary and new audio products, music servers, music streamers, computer audio, digital-to-analog converters, turntables, phono stages, cartridges, reel-to-reel tape machines, speakers, headphones and tube and solid-state amplification. Founded in 2010 What’s Best Forum invites intelligent and courteous people of all interests and backgrounds to describe and discuss the best of everything. From beginners to life-long hobbyists to industry professionals, we enjoy learning about new things and meeting new people, and participating in spirited debates.

Quick Navigation

User Menu

Steve Williams
Site Founder | Site Owner | Administrator
Ron Resnick
Site Owner | Administrator
Julian (The Fixer)
Website Build | Marketing Managersing