Elberoth,
I don't think anybody here wanted to doubt about your experience in high end

The point of confusion, and I cannot hide my own perplexity, was your statement regarding your recommendation of this product to your not-audiophile friends. That's it.
Regarding the D-Premier, I haven't heard it so far but I'd love to (standing on excited comments we are getting from forums, magazines or friends). Of course, I have no doubt there's people who can be disappointed by its performance: in the end it's just a piece of gear and it cannot be immune from criticism or delusions.
I read the review on Stereophile, here it's my impressions:
- JA really liked it
- measurements were not as stratospheric as declared (but, as we know, that's not the most important thing)
- JA recommended some care in speaker matching (no very low loads)
- the phono sections has not been reviewed. This was disappointing to me, being a vinyl lover and very curious in this not-orthodox approach (I wish a follow up by Michael Fremer soon or later)
- JA consider the $16k price "convenient" when thinking about assembling a complete (really complete!) system (cables included) with the same budget
Accordingly, I don't see hyperbolic statements such as "best ever". My interpretation of the final sentence of the review is that the "most extraordinary" doesn't go to the absolute performance, but to the concept. And with this, I think that most of the audiophiles might agree

even if, given the possibility to spend more, they might look to more orthodox systems.