I've engaged the Horenstein M3 for many years and still don't understand why it is constantly referenced for either its musical interpretation or sonics. It came out on Unicorn/Nonesuch around 1970, which is about the same time as Bernstein's M3 appeared on Sony, and the comparison couldn't be more clear. Horenstein is frankly, not a particularly good Mahlerian conductor. His tempos are all very rigid and that just doesn't work for Mahler's music. And where are his tympani's-- on permanent lunch break? The flow and movement of tempos demanded in Mahler's music is however, a perfect hand in glove fit for Bernstein, which is one reason his M3 is so revered. I haven't missed not playing Horenstein's M3 in years as it's just not a strong performance. If I want a sonic spectacular as well as a balls to the wall interpretation that Mahler would love for performance elegance, great power, wonderful rubato and fabulous playing, I'll turn to Ivan Fischer's M3 on Channel Classics SACD. Check out the end of the first movement and try not to have a stroke. Just glorious!I'll get to some modern recordings pretty soon, but Audiocrack mentioned Mahler (whose music I love), so I thought that Horenstein's 1970 performance of Mahler's Symphony No. 3, recorded by Jerry Bruck deserved a mention. I'll get to other Mahler recordings sometime, but this one is special. First, it is an iconic performance well loved by audiophiles in the Bob Auger recording for Unicorn (released in the U.S. on Nonesuch). However, while this is the same performance, it is an entirely different and independent recording made during the same sessions.
Yes, it is PCM 192kHz, so not the usual DXD or DSD256 recommendation. However, it is a direct transfer from Jerry's session tapes assembled from transfers of those session tapes by Bob Witrak of HDTT and then edited and mastered by John Haley of Harmony Restorations, LLC. The reason it was not transferred at Bob's usual DSD256 and then mastered in DXD is practicality to actually assemble it all. The session tapes are 4 tracking channels. They had never before been assembled into a full playable tape, and John says they were like ribbons of confetti with segments of just minutes long as Horenstein would coach the players, play a bit, then stop, coach, then play a bit, then stop. And, Jerry did not leave a detailed road map for how all these session tape segments should fit together. Maddening to try to assemble it all by ear, then match to the LP to ensure the performance match to the final performance Horenstein had approved for issue. And dealing with double and greater file sizes to do all the assembly required just didn't seem like a manageable project. So, it was a trade-off. But, hearing this music directly from transfers of the session tapes is a remarkable listening experience.
If you like the Horenstein performance, then you really need to hear this Jerry Bruck recording of that performance. It is so vastly superior to the overly multi-miked sonic schmush (technical term) from Bob Auger released on Unicorn. For much more information about this release from HDTT from the original session tapes, see my review:
Horenstein's Mahler Third - Jerry Bruck's Excellent Recording from HDTT
View attachment 156115
For those reading, THIS IS AN OPEN DISCUSSION. Feel free to add your own recommended recordings.
Last edited:









