I've got a bidat that I had fully modified by John Wright about 15 years as does my brother. Mine is sitting in a closet since being replaced by a musetec 005. My brother retired his a few months ago when he bought an EMM. The bidat is a fabulous, liquid, analog sounding DAC that was way ahead of its time. There are still a fair number of people who feel it is still a state of the art redbook DAC. My feeling is that it is an excellent old redbook DAC that has since been superceded by newer DACs.
if you check Impulse response of DACs you can see some DACs have perfect transient response and some other not. Optimising for having perfect Time and frequency response is not easy.
Bidat uses Special Adaptive Filter to have good response in both Time and Frequency Domain.
All NOS DACs like Audio Note DAC5 also have perfect Time domain Response.
I am not sure but I guess Wadax, Emm labs, Playback Design , Vitus , TAD , Wadia, Audio Aero, Nagra try to have good Transient Response.
Weiss, dCS , Esoteric try to have good frequency response.
please let me know If i have any mistake.
about Bidat Special Digital Filter :
"The Bidat algorithm analyzes the digital audio samples for relative accelerations and then chooses the type of filter most appropriate for that segment of data. This intelligent process results in a frequency response which is flat to 20KHz for CD playback. More important, it produces a uniquely pure impulse response without Gibb's ringing. For example, a square wave will have clean rectangular transitions and no ringing.
The Museatex Bidat can claim transient response demonstrably MORE faithful to the recorded signal than the best analog playback systems for vinyl LP's and open-reel tapes. The undistorted transient response of the Bidat means the algorithm contributes no coloration of its own to the processed audio. This performance eliminates the "digital washout" of sonic subtleties and the harshness heard in listening to a conventional interpolating algorithm. For the first time in audio engineering, the full advantage of Digital Signal Processing has been used in the service of signal fidelity by the implementation of a smart filter which could never have been built with analog circuits."