... I will say that this is turning out to be less obvious than I expected. First of all - with regard to the "negative" comments here and there about McIntosh - I thought this would be a very easy and clear comparison with a clear "looser". Brand XY will blow the Mc "out of the water" the difference will be "night and day"... etc... well - a least I can say that for my taste nothing has blown anything "out of the water" yet.
There are differences, but NOT night and day.
Also, besides objective differences with respect to whats "good" and whats "not so good" theres also that not quite so unimportant subjective aspect of personal taste.
Now - there are components that reproduce a punchier and more accurate bass, components that have more resolution, components that have a more "airy" sound... most of that comes at a price, sound gets thinner, brighter, less organic... etc. Not saying dark or bright is a good or bad thing in a judgmental way (maybe the latter is even more accurate as a reproduction) just saying that there are changes (but NOT night and day) and brands/products bring a certain character.
So does McIntosh - the separates I already own sound a little darker than most components I have compared and I would also describe them as very colorful, sometimes bold, can be very masculine/powerful and yes, maybe here and there not as fast and not the highest resolution, therefore never fatiguing though and I would say all in all very musical. There`s always a component that will do "this or that" better/different - but looking at the whole picture, I actually quite like what I have.
Also it retails for 1/2 to 1/5th the price of the products discussed here - that said, I am unsure where that leaves me... and I do wonder if its really worth spending 40 - 60k extra... I would and I`m curious to find out... but again, things are nowhere near as obvious as I expected them to be.
Cheers all and thanks for the great recommendations and information - the search goes on... ;-)
Best,
Chris