Thanks. Interesting article.
In my case, 99% of the reasons I prefer CD's are (1) the convenience of putting them on my server, access and then only listening to those songs on a particular CD that I care to and then quickly, without getting out of my chair, switching; (2) as the writer says, they are in many cases less expensive than downloads and (3) I like the physical medium for backup.
As for musical quality, both digital and analog have their strengths. Lastly, I have WAAAAAAAY more music than I will ever have time to listen to and since I am much more interested in conveniently listening to music than I am the source from which it comes, CD wins.