I think it would be creepier if they agreed on everything. Imagine if we all agreed on everything? It would make the Twilight Zone look like daycare.
Jack, you are right, of course. But he could achieve the same result by being a mensch. Imagine how many issues they would sell and how much excitement they would generate if they led with a story like a "Speaker Shootout at HP's"...And then reciprocate with a shootout at JV's....
Instead you have these ridiculous comments for a speaker debut about poor bass performance in a hotel room in a show report, out of all places.