Himalayan Salt Lamps as HiFi tweak - Snake-oil or Not?

henrich3

Active Member
Jun 7, 2022
139
103
35
Scottsdale, AZ
So Himalayan Salt lamps improve sound, and they do so by drying out the air? "They act as giant dessicants , reducing moisture in the air and thus air density and we all know that sound travels sluggishly thru thick air." Let's think about this...

First off, do they actually dry out the air? Have you ever noticed puddles of water surrounding your lamp? No? Weighing your lamp before & after being turned on for a while would certainly affirm that it didn't absorb any water, let alone the quantity of water one would need to significantly reduce a room's humidity level.

If lowering the humidity in a listening room actually did improve sound in some way, then a dehumidifier would be the proper tool to accomplish that task. Also, surely audiophiles would always be talking about how much better their systems sound in the winter because cold air is less humid than warm air.

Himalayan Salt Lamps as HiFi tweak - Snake-oil or Not? You have your answer -

 
  • Like
Reactions: Republicoftexas69

Republicoftexas69

Well-Known Member
So Himalayan Salt lamps improve sound, and they do so by drying out the air? "They act as giant desiccants , reducing moisture in the air and thus air density and we all know that sound travels sluggishly thru thick air." Let's think about this...

First off, do they actually dry out the air? Have you ever noticed puddles of water surrounding your lamp? No? Weighing your lamp before & after being turned on for a while would certainly affirm that it didn't absorb any water, let alone the quantity of water one would need to significantly reduce a room's humidity level.

If lowering the humidity in a listening room actually did improve sound in some way, then a dehumidifier would be the proper tool to accomplish that task. Also, surely audiophiles would always be talking about how much better their systems sound in the winter because cold air is less humid than warm air.

Himalayan Salt Lamps as HiFi tweak - Snake-oil or Not? You have your answer -

If you live where it gets cold in the winter.
If lowering the humidity in a listening room actually did improve sound in some way, then a dehumidifier would be the proper tool to accomplish that task. Also, surely audiophiles would always be talking about how much better their systems sound in the winter because cold air is less humid than warm air.
 

henrich3

Active Member
Jun 7, 2022
139
103
35
Scottsdale, AZ

henrich3

Active Member
Jun 7, 2022
139
103
35
Scottsdale, AZ
My audio system sounds great & I don't have a Himalayan salt lamp in my listening room. Coincidence? I don't think so...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Long Live Analog

henrich3

Active Member
Jun 7, 2022
139
103
35
Scottsdale, AZ
I don’t have them in my listening room either. The ones I have are in the bedrooms and scattered throughout the house. The lady of the house got these a long time ago.
I got one of those lamps for my mother a few years back. They're attractive. It's just bogus to claim that they improve audio in some way. I'll add "in my opinion", but some things I just know to be true without having to scour the internet for research data... ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Long Live Analog

toetapaudio

Well-Known Member
Feb 13, 2017
53
2
138
Forest of Dean UK
This is not about drying the air. It’s about reducing the noise floor due to EMI/EMF. The considerable length of cabling in our homes acts as an antenna. Noise is picked up through sockets and switches throughout your house. The Himalayan Salt reduces these EMI/EMF noises.

EMF is defined as either “Electromagnetic Field” or “Electric and Magnetic Fields”. EMF is, under either definition, a thing, an agent, or a force. EMI is defined as “Electromagnetic Interference”. EMI is the result of an electric or magnetic field acting on a device, causing it to malfunction.

There are a number of other materials and minerals that are used by the military to combat EMI and to lower the noise floor. These materials can be used to help reduce noise in our homes with very real benefits for sound systems. I’ll leave it at that unless anyone asks for advice or makes more positive comments.
 

henrich3

Active Member
Jun 7, 2022
139
103
35
Scottsdale, AZ
This is not about drying the air. It’s about reducing the noise floor due to EMI/EMF. The considerable length of cabling in our homes acts as an antenna. Noise is picked up through sockets and switches throughout your house. The Himalayan Salt reduces these EMI/EMF noises.

EMF is defined as either “Electromagnetic Field” or “Electric and Magnetic Fields”. EMF is, under either definition, a thing, an agent, or a force. EMI is defined as “Electromagnetic Interference”. EMI is the result of an electric or magnetic field acting on a device, causing it to malfunction.

There are a number of other materials and minerals that are used by the military to combat EMI and to lower the noise floor. These materials can be used to help reduce noise in our homes with very real benefits for sound systems. I’ll leave it at that unless anyone asks for advice or makes more positive comments.
Are you aware of any credible data / measurements from a trustworthy source that would support your claim that a Himalayan salt lamp reduces EMI in an audio system that's sitting nearby?
 

Tuckers

VIP/Donor
Nov 18, 2020
307
245
280
55
The story I've heard is: The act of heating the salt lamp with a bulb is supposed to generate negative ions. Some engineers say that negative ions can 'potentially' bond with EMFs, reducing them. There is science to support this theoretically. But I've also heard that the salt crystal will use up it's negative ion generating potential, and has a fairly short useful life (like a month of continuous operation). I'm not sold on any of this, but it's what I've heard from people that are less 'woo' oriented.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Republicoftexas69

Tuckers

VIP/Donor
Nov 18, 2020
307
245
280
55
The story I've heard is: The act of heating the salt lamp with a bulb is supposed to generate negative ions. Some engineers say that negative ions can 'potentially' bond with EMFs, reducing them. There is science to support this theoretically. But I've also heard that the salt crystal will use up it's negative ion generating potential, and has a fairly short useful life (like a month of continuous operation). I'm not sold on any of this, but it's what I've heard from people that are less 'woo' oriented.
Some of the contrary things I've heard about this is that negative ions that are generated have a very short lifespan in the air, so don't really have the potential to interact with either people or EMFs. And also humidity is a big influence, making reliable influence and observation.difficult. I believe humidity changes in a listening room are one reason sound varies over time in a lot of systems. Humidity influences the strength of electrostatic fields which is core to a lot of electrical function, especially how Electromagnetic Radiation moves around the outside of cables.
 
Last edited:

henrich3

Active Member
Jun 7, 2022
139
103
35
Scottsdale, AZ
The story I've heard is: The act of heating the salt lamp with a bulb is supposed to generate negative ions. Some engineers say that negative ions can 'potentially' bond with EMFs, reducing them. There is science to support this theoretically. But I've also heard that the salt crystal will use up it's negative ion generating potential, and has a fairly short useful life (like a month of continuous operation). I'm not sold on any of this, but it's what I've heard from people that are less 'woo' oriented.

Some of the contrary things I've heard about this is that negative ions that are generated have a very short lifespan in the air, so don't really have the potential to interact with either people or EMFs. And also humidity is a big influence, making reliable influence and observation.difficult.
That's just speculation, of course. There's a big difference between hypothesizing a plausible reason for a hoped for result, and actually measuring lower EMI noise.

I have a Greenwave Broadband EMI Meter. I also just ordered a Himalayan salt lamp. (Since I haven't had much luck finding Christmas gifts for my wife, I thought that the lamp might make a nice stocking stuffer.) I can borrow the lamp & measure the EMI in the power line going to my audio gear after Christmas. I have zero expectations that the lamp will reduce EMI, but since I already have the meter I'm willing to test this.
 

Republicoftexas69

Well-Known Member
That's just speculation, of course. There's a big difference between hypothesizing a plausible reason for a hoped for result, and actually measuring lower EMI noise.

I have a Greenwave Broadband EMI Meter. I also just ordered a Himalayan salt lamp. (Since I haven't had much luck finding Christmas gifts for my wife, I thought that the lamp might make a nice stocking stuffer.) I can borrow the lamp & measure the EMI in the power line going to my audio gear after Christmas. I have zero expectations that the lamp will reduce EMI, but since I already have the meter I'm willing to test this.
I think ASR might be missing you. :rolleyes:
 

BruceD

VIP/Donor
Dec 13, 2013
1,509
576
540
Word of caution--I have these lamps and the damn things leave a mess of caked salt on and around the bases so place in receptacles/saucer/etc. Be warned;)

They do look nice on though :)

BruceD
 
  • Like
Reactions: henrich3

Tuckers

VIP/Donor
Nov 18, 2020
307
245
280
55
I think ASR might be missing you. :rolleyes:
Should lookup the review ASR did of the Greenwave broadband. Even Amir had a hard time covering it. The Greenwave is good at one thing at least: Supporting a whole industry of "EMR Specialists" and selling consulting and solutions in this area.
 
  • Like
Reactions: henrich3

treitz3

Super Moderator
Staff member
Dec 25, 2011
5,459
961
1,290
The tube lair in beautiful Rock Hill, SC
That's just speculation, of course. There's a big difference between hypothesizing a plausible reason for a hoped for result, and actually measuring lower EMI noise.

I have a Greenwave Broadband EMI Meter. I also just ordered a Himalayan salt lamp. (Since I haven't had much luck finding Christmas gifts for my wife, I thought that the lamp might make a nice stocking stuffer.) I can borrow the lamp & measure the EMI in the power line going to my audio gear after Christmas. I have zero expectations that the lamp will reduce EMI, but since I already have the meter I'm willing to test this.
So, as I understand this....you have ZERO experience with salt lamps, yet you are spewing your thoughts?

Please tell me that this not the case.

Tom
 

About us

  • What’s Best Forum is THE forum for high end audio, product reviews, advice and sharing experiences on the best of everything else. This is THE place where audiophiles and audio companies discuss vintage, contemporary and new audio products, music servers, music streamers, computer audio, digital-to-analog converters, turntables, phono stages, cartridges, reel-to-reel tape machines, speakers, headphones and tube and solid-state amplification. Founded in 2010 What’s Best Forum invites intelligent and courteous people of all interests and backgrounds to describe and discuss the best of everything. From beginners to life-long hobbyists to industry professionals, we enjoy learning about new things and meeting new people, and participating in spirited debates.

Quick Navigation

User Menu

Steve Williams
Site Founder | Site Owner | Administrator
Ron Resnick
Site Co-Owner | Administrator
Julian (The Fixer)
Website Build | Marketing Managersing