Koetsu

View attachment 158526

Hey Steve!

What can I say… I like to live on the edge? Use the back as a dust sweep?

I’ll defer to @J.R. Boisclair for all the technicalities but from my understanding the native SRA is quite steep, and mine even on the steeper end of the Koetsu builds. So this was to correct for that.
Yea as I said earlier, J. R. knows what he’s doing, so this must be the best approach to optimizing this particular Blue Lace, which by the way looks absolutely beautiful!!

/ Jk
 
  • Love
Reactions: keithc
View attachment 158526

Hey Steve!

What can I say… I like to live on the edge? Use the back as a dust sweep?

I’ll defer to @J.R. Boisclair for all the technicalities but from my understanding the native SRA is quite steep, and mine even on the steeper end of the Koetsu builds. So this was to correct for that.
Yes, this cartridge needed 13 degrees of VTA correction and in the range of 9 degrees of SRA correction. The cartridge body interfered, however, so the most I was able to get was 4 degrees of correction. You can also see the 0.9 degrees of azimuth correction. On the upside, the zenith error was less than 1 degree. This error will add extra 2nd harmonic distortion - which is one reason why it sounds as you describe. However, as I say in my videos, you cannot get something for nothing in mechanical transcription. That added distortion comes at the cost of overall clarity and sense of "focus" that gives you the soundstaging and imaging that only analog can deliver. This issue is exacerbated at 33rpm at the inner area of the record. Vast majority of people (including me) don't notice the problem until you remove it - and then you never want to go back to the way it was.

You might wonder why two cartridges that are very different in pricing don’t sound dramatically different from each other. I address this in one of my videos entitled “why do some Audiophiles own multiple cartridges?“
 
Last edited:
View attachment 158526

Hey Steve!

What can I say… I like to live on the edge? Use the back as a dust sweep?

I’ll defer to @J.R. Boisclair for all the technicalities but from my understanding the native SRA is quite steep, and mine even on the steeper end of the Koetsu builds. So this was to correct for that.
Ooo Wow .... that's a huge shim that J.R. has had to have made and fitted for some serious cartridge SRA, VTA, Azimuth etc. correction !
Makes you wonder hey that such an expensive cartridge requires such huge corrections !
Maybe the cartridge maker had a bad day the day he was building this cartridge and maybe a few to many Saki's the night before lol :)
 
Ooo Wow .... that's a huge shim that J.R. has had to have made and fitted for some serious cartridge SRA, VTA, Azimuth etc. correction !
Makes you wonder hey that such an expensive cartridge requires such huge corrections !
Maybe the cartridge maker had a bad day the day he was building this cartridge and maybe a few to many Saki's the night before lol :)
I’ve seen far worse costing more than this one. There is one ~$15k cartridge I’ve seen four times in the lab. Zenith errors were 20.2, 9.9, 14.5 & 4.9 degrees.

Over 30 people have reported hearing as little as 0.5 degrees of zenith error. It is quite an audibly sensitive parameter
 
If they can make extreme high tech micro/nano chips, why can’t they make a 100% correct and fully functional cartridge which in terms are way bigger then the tiny parts inside a microchip?

Somebody explain to me, please!
 
If they can make extreme high tech micro/nano chips, why can’t they make a 100% correct and fully functional cartridge which in terms are way bigger then the tiny parts inside a microchip?

Somebody explain to me, please!
Multiple reasons: market doesn’t know about the problem so there is no urgency to fix. Even cartridge manufacturers don’t measure what they buy from Ogura/Orbray/Gyger for all angular parameters. There is also the issue of ossification on the part of the companies mentioned above and the cartridge makers themselves, particularly in Japan. There is also the issue that the volumes aren’t great enough to invest in the expensive technology that would offer consistency.

Uniformly, when people hear their cartridge after optimization, they do not “go back” to previous setups, but the problems do not advertise themselves as needing attention prior to optimization; so pretty much everyone is “happy where they are”. The point being that we don’t know what we are missing until we’ve heard it.
 
I’ve seen far worse costing more than this one. There is one ~$15k cartridge I’ve seen four times in the lab. Zenith errors were 20.2, 9.9, 14.5 & 4.9 degrees.

Over 30 people have reported hearing as little as 0.5 degrees of zenith error. It is quite an audibly sensitive parameter

The cartridge you are discussing is a 15k cartridge

@Johan K - are you sending your Blue Lace to JR so he can tell you how bad it is, and your hearing :p
if it's sound good , it is good :cool:
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Johan K
Don’t try such corrections by changing arm height. Doing so upsets multiple vector forces so you’ll never hear JUST the impact of improving VTA. I’ve done videos on this.
Hi J.R,
Yes I hold my hand up for doing this with my MSL Eminent Ex i.e. raising my Kuzma XL DC Arm Tower up to 7mm from the horizontal tonearm point to get an ideal (as per current guidance etc.) SRA etc. for this cartridge !
 
Multiple reasons: market doesn’t know about the problem so there is no urgency to fix. Even cartridge manufacturers don’t measure what they buy from Ogura/Orbray/Gyger for all angular parameters. There is also the issue of ossification on the part of the companies mentioned above and the cartridge makers themselves, particularly in Japan. There is also the issue that the volumes aren’t great enough to invest in the expensive technology that would offer consistency.

Uniformly, when people hear their cartridge after optimization, they do not “go back” to previous setups, but the problems do not advertise themselves as needing attention prior to optimization; so pretty much everyone is “happy where they are”. The point being that we don’t know what we are missing until we’ve heard it.
Thank you !
 
The cartridge you are discussing is a 15k cartridge

@Johan K - are you sending your Blue Lace to JR so he can tell you how bad it is, and your hearing :p
if it's sound good , it is good :cool:
Btw - never heard of a cartridge that expensive.. LOL..!!

-As hobby money is no money ☝ :D
 
  • Haha
Reactions: XV-1

About us

  • What’s Best Forum is THE forum for high end audio, product reviews, advice and sharing experiences on the best of everything else. This is THE place where audiophiles and audio companies discuss vintage, contemporary and new audio products, music servers, music streamers, computer audio, digital-to-analog converters, turntables, phono stages, cartridges, reel-to-reel tape machines, speakers, headphones and tube and solid-state amplification. Founded in 2010 What’s Best Forum invites intelligent and courteous people of all interests and backgrounds to describe and discuss the best of everything. From beginners to life-long hobbyists to industry professionals, we enjoy learning about new things and meeting new people, and participating in spirited debates.

Quick Navigation

User Menu

Steve Williams
Site Founder | Site Owner | Administrator
Ron Resnick
Site Owner | Administrator
Julian (The Fixer)
Website Build | Marketing Managersing