Magico Q7

caesar · Apr 13, 2013

Gentlemen, so why are there 3 Q7's listed on Audiogon only a year after the speaker went it production and declared as the most important component in the last 23 years???? One of the 3 has only 12 hours left, so better hurry!

No, I am not a Magico hater, but an audiophile with a demonic passion to find gear that sound like real music. For those that love the Magico sound, snatch the Q7's before they are gone. I hope you find eternal bliss with the Q7. But for those that share my philosophy, think hard why people who have lived with the speaker got rid of it after such a short period of time.

Andre Marc · Apr 13, 2013

caesar said:
Gentlemen, so why are there 3 Q7's listed on Audiogon only a year after the speaker went it production and declared as the most important component in the last 23 years???? One of the 3 has only 12 hours left, so better hurry!

No, I am not a Magico hater, but an audiophile with a demonic passion to find gear that sound like real music. For those that love the Magico sound, snatch the Q7's before they are gone. I hope you find eternal bliss with the Q7. But for those that share my philosophy, think hard why people who have lived with the speaker got rid of it after such a short period of time.

Audiophile Nervosa Merry Go Round.

Or..men with too much money and time on their hands who get bored.

caesar · Apr 13, 2013

Andre Marc said:
Audiophile Nervosa Merry Go Round.

Or..men with too much money and time on their hands who get bored.

Maybe so. But Alexandria XLF was released at the same time and there are none of those on the market.

I remember seeing a while back some pictures or a video of Alon Wolf, industry insiders (the goateed Magico dude who sets up their speakers at shows, some other manufacturers, etc.), and some reviewers (Valin? Harley? Soundstage Guys, etc.) having a fancy dinner, eating lobster, steak, and sipping wine. I'm sure it was a great night and I wish I were invited. But as they ate, their braisn swooned with intense pleasure. Did the reviewers, afterwards, seriously evaluate the speaker? Did they think of their readers and how they listen and what they enjoy? Did they probe and apply critical thinking skills? The answer is no (and probably would have been no even without the fancy dinner). These guys heard the transparency and the detail and called it BEST. They did not question their conclusions or play devil's advocate. Then the customers and their readers shopping for the speaker only focused on the positives and the accolades. And after only a couple of months, it's audiophile nervosa, as you say.

If these guys are billionaires, no big loss. But many of guys, despite being very rich, are probably not billionaires and still make tradeoffs. I'm sure they are somewhat pissed.

Andre Marc · Apr 13, 2013

caesar said:
Maybe so. But Alexandria XLF was released at the same time and there are none of those on the market.

I remember seeing a while back some pictures or a video of Alon Wolf, industry insiders (the goateed Magico dude who sets up their speakers at shows, some other manufacturers, etc.), and some reviewers (Valin? Harley? Soundstage Guys, etc.) having a fancy dinner, eating lobster, steak, and sipping wine. I'm sure it was a great night and I wish I were invited. But as they ate, their braisn swooned with intense pleasure. Did the reviewers, afterwards, seriously evaluate the speaker? Did they think of their readers and how they listen and what they enjoy? Did they probe and apply critical thinking skills? The answer is no (and probably would have been no even without the fancy dinner). These guys heard the transparency and the detail and called it BEST. They did not question their conclusions or play devil's advocate. Then the customers and their readers shopping for the speaker only focused on the positives and the accolades. And after only a couple of months, it's audiophile nervosa, as you say.

If these guys are billionaires, no big loss. But many of guys, despite being very rich, are probably not billionaires and still make tradeoffs. I'm sure they are somewhat pissed.

Too many questions and speculation here..

I will just say that if you drop 180 LARGE on any audio product without listening to it with familiar music and electronics,
I would be shedding a tear for you if you don't like it a year later. That is what you would call a very posh "problem" to have.
Gimme a break LOL.

I am not wealthy, but I am not struggling either, and I account for every dollar I spend. I just ordered some input tubes for the Carber amp
for 50 bucks and I spend weeks shopping for the right tube.

I don't wanna hear about poor rich old men who buy something based on rave reviews then regret it.

Bruce B · Apr 13, 2013

Well one pair was just relisted for 99k. Seems he couldn't get any offers at first listing for $125k

caesar · Apr 13, 2013

Andre Marc said:
Too many questions and speculation here..

I will just say that if you drop 180 LARGE on any audio product without listening to it with familiar music and electronics,
I would be shedding a tear for you if you don't like it a year later. That is what you would call a very posh "problem" to have.
Gimme a break LOL.

I am not wealthy, but I am not struggling either, and I account for every dollar I spend. I just ordered some input tubes for the Carber amp
for 50 bucks and I spend weeks shopping for the right tube.

I don't wanna hear about poor rich old men who buy something based on rave reviews then regret it.

Where's your empathy for your fellow brother-audiophile?

Andre Marc · Apr 13, 2013

caesar said:
Where's your empathy for your fellow brother-audiophile?

I'll save my tears for those really deserve it, like those poor over taxed hedge fund managers.

still-one · Apr 13, 2013

caesar said:
Gentlemen, so why are there 3 Q7's listed on Audiogon only a year after the speaker went it production and declared as the most important component in the last 23 years???? One of the 3 has only 12 hours left, so better hurry!

No, I am not a Magico hater, but an audiophile with a demonic passion to find gear that sound like real music. For those that love the Magico sound, snatch the Q7's before they are gone. I hope you find eternal bliss with the Q7. But for those that share my philosophy, think hard why people who have lived with the speaker got rid of it after such a short period of time.

It is possible that the sound that the average audio enthusiast seeks is very different from that of certain reviewers. We all have our own idea of what a great speaker should sound like and a reviewers "Best" might sound un-involving once you get it in your own home. If I was interested in a speaker at this price point I would have flown in for a listen before ordering.

edorr · Apr 13, 2013

caesar said:
Where's your empathy for your fellow brother-audiophile?

These are indeed heartbreaking stories. Dreams shattered, college funds depleted...... I suggest we set up a WBF Q7's victims fund. Donations are welcome. Now collecting old cables for silent auction.

microstrip · Apr 13, 2013

The Q7 are great speakers - I listened to them twice, one of the times it was playing really good.

However there is a disappointing aspect in it - the 94 dB/W rating can be misleading, as its users are saying it needs really large power - many hundreds of watts seem the minimum. I can imagine that any one betting on a speaker for medium power tubes will be disappointed and will soon look for a XLF or similar.

Andre Marc · Apr 13, 2013

microstrip said:
The Q7 are great speakers - I listened to them twice, one of the times it was playing really good.

However there is a disappointing aspect in it - the 94 dB/W rating can be misleading, as its users are saying it needs really large power - many hundreds of watts seem the minimum. I can imagine that any one betting on a speaker for medium power tubes will be disappointed and will soon look for a XLF.

Robert Harley drove them with very low powered Lamm mono blocks and raved about the combo.

Andre Marc · Apr 13, 2013

edorr said:
These are indeed heartbreaking stories. Dreams shattered, college funds depleted...... I suggest we set up a WBF Q7's victims fund. Donations are welcome. Now collecting old cables for silent auction.

andromedaaudio · Apr 13, 2013

Well no problem there guys , if i was not making speakers myself , a used Q 7 would certainly be a speaker i would want to pick up
Great speaker

A impedance / efficiency test by JA would be welcome

microstrip · Apr 13, 2013

Andre Marc said:
Robert Harley drove them with very low powered Lamm mono blocks and raved about the combo.

Yes, but as far as I know Lamm's ML2.1, ML2.2 and ML3 are exceptions in this aspect in the high-arena - I would love to know why. AFAIR Steve Williams told us once that the ML2.1 would easily drive the Maxx2 or 3!

Andre Marc · Apr 13, 2013

andromedaaudio said:
Well no problem there guys , if i was not making speakers myself , a used Q 7 would certainly be a speaker i would want to pick up
Great speaker

A impedance / efficiency test by JA would be welcome

To be clear, I think Magico makes very very impressive speakers. I have nothing bad to say about the Q7.

Like many other things in life it is a rich toy for a rich boy.

I think the Q series is clearly a leap forward in speaker design.

andromedaaudio · Apr 13, 2013

Personally i dont like all the Q series speakers , and i might have liked it more with a soft dome or ringradiator in the long run .
But its a work of industial design inside and the front is nice , also very nice membrane material , and a flat response off course
Its a speaker with which you can MAKE a sound , not the speaker making the sound for you by having a very personal character and influencing the music that way .
Just my 2 cents

microstrip · Apr 13, 2013

andromedaaudio said:
Personally i dont like all the Q series speakers , and i might have liked it more with a soft dome or ringradiator in the long run .
But its a work of industial design inside and the front is nice , also very nice membrane material , and a flat response off course (...)

Do you have access to measurements of the Q series? The very few I found do not seem to be "flat response".

andromedaaudio · Apr 13, 2013

No , i have not but i ve read about other magico speaker measurements and iirc they were reasonably flat +- 3db over most of the audioband 1/6 smoothe factor
Also by hearing i dont think they were much out of line , only it could have had a bit more bass , but maybe it was the zanden poweramps running out of juice

andromedaaudio · Apr 13, 2013

http://www.stereophile.com/content/magico-q5-loudspeaker-measurements

Q 5 against maxx 3 , maxx 3 is a bit flatter but if you start from 400 hz the Q 5 is very flat also

LL21 · Apr 13, 2013

andromedaaudio said:
http://www.stereophile.com/content/magico-q5-loudspeaker-measurements

Q 5 against maxx 3 , maxx 3 is a bit flatter but if you start from 400 hz the Q 5 is very flat also

Now that is interesting. I have always liked Wilsons and given the choice would choose the bigger Wilsons over the equivalently priced Magico. but i was told by a reviewer that the bigger Wilsons are not linear, etc...and the Magico extremely linear. From what you say...the opposite, if any thing is true.

Deeply respect the Magicos...just surprised to hear the Maxx 3 is a bit flatter than Q5.

Magico Q7

Well-Known Member

Member Sponsor

Well-Known Member

Member Sponsor

WBF Founding Member, Pro Audio Production Member

Well-Known Member

Member Sponsor

VIP/Donor

WBF Founding Member

VIP/Donor

Member Sponsor

Member Sponsor

VIP/Donor

VIP/Donor

Member Sponsor

VIP/Donor

VIP/Donor

VIP/Donor

VIP/Donor

Well-Known Member

Similar threads