Old vs. new violins; the perils of blind testing?

rbbert said:

As mentioned early on in this thread, the study referenced in the OP is a (sort of) follow-up to the hotel room study. I believe that instead of a hotel room, this was performed in a concert hall, and instead of welder's goggles a soft blindfold was used. In any case, the title of this thread should give some clue as to my position regarding this study...

Click to expand...

jkeny said:

Thanks, Tim - it looks lik ethis place needed a bit of livening up
I see you haven't changed
Let's restart from where we left off - are you really trying to say I'm in denial based on this first paper? I presume you haven't read the second paper?

Click to expand...

Phelonious Ponk said:

Not trying to say anything John.

Tim

Click to expand...